September 02, 2026
Upcycling Vintage and Antique Quilts in Sewing - Exploring the Ethics

Recent trends have increased the popularity of cutting up vintage, antique, and heirloom quilts and blankets for sewing projects. The results are certainly stunning, to be sure; however, this practice is not without controversy. As a result, you may be asking yourself whether or not it’s right, or ethical, to do so. We invite you to explore the ethics for yourself, as you follow along with a vintage-quilt journey near and dear to T+T team member Erica's heart, considering many of the questions you might want to ask for your own vintage textile project.

The big question: is it OK to cut up a vintage quilt to sew with?

The simple answer? There is no simple answer. Like so many things in life, there is a great deal of nuance and history that one should consider before doing so - not just out of respect to the original maker, but also the history the quilt holds in each and every stitch.

I found myself faced with this same question just a few months ago, when the stars aligned and my mother found a large tote of unfinished quilt tops, just before I travelled across the country to visit her. An incredible collection of nearly 20, these quilt tops were created by my great-grandmother over an unknown period of years…possibly even decades. My mother, knowing she wouldn’t be able to finish them all herself, invited my four sisters and I to take our own to finish quilting, thus allowing her grandmother’s legacy to live on, in a small part, through all of us. 

A woman wearing a Loft Quilted Jacket made from a vintage star quilt holds out a photo towards the camera, of a man and woman in their Sunday best standing in front of a flower bed

So, why would someone cut up a quilt for a project?

It’s hard to deny the appeal of making projects with vintage quilts - a piece made from a vintage quilt holds a charm and whimsy that is hard to match in modern textiles. They often carry a sense of nostalgia, especially when the quilt has a family history.

There’s a very human element to them too: small delicate hand-stitches, placed lovingly decades ago. Worn corners where a child rubbed the binding between their fingers hundreds of times. Fading from countless sunny picnics. Each and every detail tells a story, and incorporating those in a new project has a beautifully circular quality. 

Of course, we haven’t even brushed the surface of the practical reasons as well - from availability, to economy, to the convenience of something being pre-quilted and more!

Looking at my grandmother’s quilt tops, I found myself lost in all the tiny little details - the living proof of all the hours she spent stitching these intricate tops. “Hexies” as small as an inch across. Tiny little knots where each seam started and finished. Even, upon closer inspection, spots where small pieces were pieced even further to make precious scraps stretch further. 

I never got to meet my great-grandmother, as she passed away shortly before my birth, but I instantly felt connected with her story in a way that was hard to put into words. To find myself with an opportunity to add depth to her story, both literally and figuratively, feels like such an honor.

A close-up collage shows tiny details in a hand-sewn vintage quilt top. These include tiny little knots and stitches, stripes lined up into perfect designs across the pieces of a star, and extra little pieces added to make too-small scraps work.

Well, that sounds nice - what’s the problem, then?

The concerns about upcycling vintage quilts stem from many of the same reasons that people love using them - each one is an undeniable piece of someone’s history, either personally or collectively. Many hold cultural significance as well. While some believe that using these textiles is a way to honour that legacy, still others believe that it does the opposite, and erases their effort and care: quite literally, cutting it to pieces. 

The irreplaceability of these one-of-a-kind textiles plays a part as well - they are a limited resource. Time marches slowly on, and eventually, all things succumb to age. Fabrics are especially prone to this, no matter how careful one is about storing them. This means that the numbers of these quilts are diminishing more each and every year. There is certainly an argument to be made that there is value in preserving them carefully, in their intended state, to be enjoyed as a part of history for as long as possible. 

Looking through my great-grandmother’s collection of quilt tops, I couldn’t help but marvel at how good of shape many of them were in. We don’t have a lot of information about their age, but many were still in remarkably good condition! Unfortunately, though, some of them showed signs of wear…from what, we aren’t entirely sure. Multiple cross-country moves, less than ideal storage conditions, and a great many other factors may have taken part.

A close-up photo shows the damaged that has been previously sustained to a vintage quilt, before being made into a Loft Quilted Jacket. The holes run down the length of the center of a quilt top.

Oh yes…I can see how that becomes challenging. So, who’s right?

Rather than a question of “right” or “wrong”, we want to reiterate that this is somewhat of a matter of personal conviction, and each situation must be considered with care rather than passing blanket judgement. There may be many situations where both answers could be “right”, and some thoughtful reflection should always be employed before cutting into these quilts at random. 

This is the sort of debate that often comes up when we, as humans, disagree over whether something’s material integrity is more important than its functional or relational significance - that is to say, whether something is more valuable based on its existence, or fulfilling its function or human connection. 

A mostly purple and white quilt top hangs on a brick wall, featuring multicolor "wandering" curved stripes. It features a scalloped edge.

Here’s an example, in terms of quilts: it could be said that much of the time, a quilt’s purpose and function is to provide warmth, comfort, and even a passing-along of love and connection. (Of course this is a bit reductionist - quilts can also be created and valuable specifically for their artistry, to memorialise a significant event or movement, or so much more - but for the purposes of this illustration, we are focusing more on the everyday quilts one is more likely to find tucked away in their linen closets or antique stores.) 

If the value of the quilt is placed in its material integrity as an artifact, then tucking it away in a hope chest, to be admired gingerly on occasion, could be considered the “right” choice for its preservation. Even in terms of emotional significance, this may feel like the most respectful decision, to allow a longer time for the maker’s legacy to live on, without exposure to wear and tear.

A young woman has a star-covered quilt top wrapped around her shoulders as it appears to fly in a breeze. She is surrounded by trees.

However, when the focus is placed on its functional significance, instead, then figuring out how to treat it looks a bit different. From this viewpoint, reshaping the quilt into a coat aligns with its value perfectly - it’s still providing comfort and warmth, just in a different form. Even in terms of emotional connection, reshaping it may actually make it easier to enjoy in a wider variety of situations, allowing for one to feel the connection with its maker like a warm hug, no matter where they are. And, in terms of passing along as an heirloom, it can often be done just as easily in a new form, as its original form.

Where the value of a deeply personal object like a quilt lies is extremely individual, and the nuance of this should always be respected. That’s why the answers can come in many shades of grey…and that’s OK.

As my mother and I looked through the collection of quilt tops, we started to have a really thoughtful discussion about what would be the most respectful way to approach them. They felt like they had more potential than sitting unfinished…but in the end, we found our answers varied from top to top. Just continuing to keep them felt as-is disrespectful to my great-grandmother’s memory, but so did wanton attacks with scissors. We decided that our plans, then, deserved careful consideration piece by piece.

A collection of three vintage quilt tops lays on top of a brick wall, including the star quilt which is being upcycled for this Loft Quilted Jacket project.

Questions to ask yourself when you want to make something with a vintage quilt

At the end of the day, we believe that there are both opportunities for respectful upcycling, as well as situations where it should be avoided. We find it helpful to consider a variety of questions in your decision making - here’s a few of them (along with my own answers, as I approached projects with this quilt top collection!)

  • Does this quilt hold specific cultural, historical or artistic value? At risk of sounding obvious, if there’s any chance that the quilt in question holds significant cultural, historical or artistic value, it should not be cut up. This can be considered on both on a macro or micro level. Even if something may not be nationally meaningful, if it holds special significance to family members, or stands as part of a very limited example of one’s life, then it may be worth preserving in its whole state. 
    Different forms of quilting have played a part in many cultural practices throughout the world as well, and extreme care should be paid towards respecting this, and preventing cultural erasure of marginalised groups. We invite you to come back soon and take a look at some examples of quilting across culture and history - not just for appreciation, but more importantly, as a means of understanding their identity and significance, and so that you can learn to identify some of these cultural pieces if you ever happened across them.

    My great-grandmother lived her life quite simply and plainly - which is beautiful, no doubt, but leaves her quilt tops as something without significant value outside of our family. They are tied to neither place nor period. That said, there are tops in the collection that no one in my family would ever dream of cutting up - for instance, the one where she lovingly stitched the names of family and friends, to preserve their bond at that point in time. 

    A quilt lays over a bench, featuring tens of named embroidered on individual blocks/
  • Are you the person who would be considered the rightful steward of the quilt as an artifact? If not, do you have permission of the person/people who are? Ultimately, a familial heirloom can be considered an inheritance, and as such, the responsibility for its care, and therefore decisions about it, are generally passed on to a specific person. This may be the next of kin, the person who received it as a gift, or a variety of other situations. You should always very carefully consider talking to everyone who has a rightful say in its condition prior to cutting up a quilt: not just to prevent strained family relationships, but out of respect to the maker’s wishes.
    My mother is the only child of an only child - one of her fondest memories of her grandmother is her telling my father to take good care of her, wagging her finger saying  “she’s the only one I’ve got!” Therefore, as the next living descendant, I am more than willing to defer to my mother’s wishes as the final say of what happens to any of these pieces. If she didn’t want them cut up, they wouldn’t be - full stop.

  • Is this quilt of archival quality - that is to say, is it in good shape and able to be preserved for a long haul? Or is there damage that would be difficult to repair?A sad reality is that not all remaining vintage quilts are in a state that would lend themselves well to archival display or maintenance. If yours is, it may be worth keeping it that way, especially if it is among a collection that has experienced further decay.
    We are blessed to be able to say that many of our familial collection of quilt tops are in great condition. These, we want to keep whole as long as possible, and have decided collectively not to cut up. However, a couple of the tops had sustained some damage that would be difficult to repair, and would threaten their integrity of being used as a whole blanket - they do have sound areas, though. And so, my mother has given the go-ahead for other items to be made with them, provided that we are utilizing as much of them as possible. 

    Three colorful vintage quilt tops are neatly folded and placed one atop another on a brick bench.
  • From what you know of the original maker, would repurposing the quilt honor their intent, wishes, and/or personality? This answer to this question can take on a variety of different forms, and all should be carefully considered. For instance, was the quilt made with the intention of display as a complete art quilt? If so, cutting it up could be akin to cutting up a fine art piece to make postcards. Was it made with specific fabrics that are meaningful to a single person? It shouldn’t be split, but kept in one way or another as a complete set of memories. Did the maker have a very “use what you have” mentality? They probably would, in fact, be quite honoured if they knew their piece was being conserved in a way that would be meaningfully used. These questions, and their answers, will be very individual, so take a little time to sit with the quilt and analyze them prior to making a decision.
    My great-grandmother was a very pragmatic maker, who didn’t necessarily come from much. She spent much of her life getting by on what could be scraped together for survival. However, even in that situation she wove together a beautiful life, and was well loved for her ability to create plenty from very little with immense kindness. She didn’t create things just to be looked at, for the most part - she made them to be used. To create items from these damaged quilts, that furthers their utility, feels like a wonderful tribute to her resourcefulness and skill.

  • Is this quilt irreplaceable? Please understand my meaning clearly: every quilt is unique, and stunning, and beautiful. Each is a one-of-a-kind piece in its own right. However, some have qualities that make them more irreplaceable than others, such as if they are the only remaining example of someone’s skills; include a skill that is in danger of being lost to time; or portray a one-of-a-kind artistry. However, many quilts you may encounter look fairly similar in terms of their fabrics, piecing, and more - due to their volume, these could be considered somewhat less precious in terms of considering their preservation.
    We are blessed to have a robust collection of my great-grandmother’s quilt tops remaining. Some are more intricate and beautiful, while others are a bit more utilitarian in comparison. However, no individual quilt top is the last remaining testament to her skill. As this is the case, and we have plenty of quilts to keep whole in her memory, utilizing the damaged ones for a jacket will not be detracting from the collection or her memory. 

    An intricate, colorful quilt on a white field is laid on top of a brick bench. The design is made entirely of tiny hexagons, no more than an inch across.
  • What is the quilt’s fate, if not used for your project? While the collection of vintage quilts in the world is dwindling, there are still quite a lot of them relegated to the back of musty linen closets - or worse, the op shop bins. Museums only have the capacity or desire to save so many. The sad truth is that in many cases, people may view these quilts in their possession as something old fashioned, or out of style, and so they simply give them away or throw them out. In these instances, passing on using a quilt for a project may not actually lead to its preservation. Especially if you’ve encountered it somewhere like an op shop or community giving page, there may be a very real chance that it will end up in a landfill or as a dog blanket, and lost forever. This is especially true for pieces that are damaged. In these situations, if you aren’t able to keep the blanket in its whole form, then a sewing project may be one of its last chances to be appreciated.
    Of course, my great-grandmother’s quilt tops will be loved and admired, no matter their state. We are committed to finding the best ways we can to preserve her memory. However, in the case of the damaged blankets, there’s a chance that they could become further damaged in storage, or relegated to the end of the line for finishing, and so creating jackets with them actually allows them to be enjoyed more.

  • Can the quilt you are considering actually stand up to the use you are planning for it? Many antique quilts show signs of their age, and can suffer from UV, pest, and wear damage. This may leave everything from holes, to thinning fabric, dye degradation, and more. While there are techniques you can use to stabilise and repair them, it may be good to consider realistically whether or not they can stand up to the wear and tear of life as a garment, and exposure to friction, pulling, environmental factors and more. Also, if you don’t know how they were damaged, is it possible that the reason has caused other, unseen damage that may give way?
    This consideration gave me a bit of pause in my case - I don’t know exactly what caused these holes to occur, and therefore I don’t know with 100% certainty if there may be more extensive damage that I can’t see. However, in inspecting this top more closely, it really is in quite good shape except for along the quilt’s center, so I suspect that being folded up for too long is what has caused the damage. I will avoid using this central line, and reinforce the rest of the quilt using a variety of different techniques, which should help it stand up the way I need it to. In fact, arguably, it will stand up better as a jacket than as a blanket - we tend to be hard on blankets in my house, whereas my jacket will see slightly lighter use in my warm climate.

    A woman dons a Loft Quilted Jacket made from the vintage quilt top featured in earlier photos. The photo shows her putting the jacket on from behind, standing on a wooden walkway in the woods.

If you’re a sewist who has considered crafting with vintage quilts, I hope you have found this an insightful look into the nuanced decision-making involved. For some additional tips on how to work with your vintage blanket to preserve its integrity and hardiness, we invite you to follow along with this quilt top’s journey towards becoming a jacket, in its next chapter talking all about the practicalities of working with these unique textiles. We’ll be sharing a look at conservation techniques, cutting considerations, and more - we hope you’ll enjoy a look at the process, just as much as we have enjoyed watching it come together.

A woman in a white tshirt and jeans walks down a wooden boardwalk, with a colorful star-covered Loft Quilted Jacket slung over her shoulder.

Here's some additional quilt-curious content you may enjoy:

Featuring photos by Erica Wright and Eunice Flick Pallagi